Staten Island, NY

Five Italian Restaurants in Staten Island, New York

Katie Cherrix

Staten Island is NYC's southernmost borough boasting pretty beaches and more natural space than the other four. There are so many reasons to love Staten Island, and this unique part of New York has some of the best food in the city. Italian cuisine is a New York staple, and you'll find some of the city's finest in these Staten Island Italian restaurants.

Nino's Restaurant

Nino's has been serving Staten Island with white-tablecloth Italian dining since 1994. Their authentic Italian menu includes antipasti, zuppa, risotto, salads, and traditional entrees that are satisfying and delicious. With a friendly wait staff and beautiful dining rooms, Nino's is the perfect place to go for an intimate, romantic date night. Enjoy authentic Italian cuisine made from fresh ingredients and a nice glass of wine at Nino's Restaurant in Staten Island.

Il Sogno

Patrons of Il Sogno will enjoy a dreamy dining experience at this opulent Italian restaurant. Whether you are having dinner for two or dining with a large group, you will be impressed by the exceptional service, upscale atmosphere, and expertly prepared Italian cuisine. Menu favorites include the pear salad, shrimp scampi, and grillata mixta, along with the delicious daily specials. They also have a prix fixe menu you can choose if you can't decide what to order. Il Sogno has something for everyone to enjoy, and it's easy to see why they are one of the best Italian restaurants in Staten Island.


Piccolino's is one of Staten Island's most well-loved Italian restaurants. Everything from the dining atmosphere to the carefully crafted dishes work to create an unforgettable experience. Patrons rave about the friendly wait staff, and the new prix fixe menu is becoming increasingly popular. Piccolino's is the perfect place to celebrate any special occasion, and it's easily one of the top Italian restaurants in Staten Island.


Since 1996, Italianissimo has welcomed Staten Island diners to enjoy traditional Italian cuisine in a warm, inviting setting. Chef Franco Ortega has a true passion for crafting Italian dishes that exceed customer expectations every time. The road to becoming a Chef wasn't easy for Ortega, but his love for food and dedication to excellence allowed him to build one of the best Italian restaurants in Staten Island. Rich pasta dishes, fresh salads, hearty Italian soups, and entrees featuring high-quality proteins are always on the menu at Italianissimo.

Trattoria Toscana

Trattoria Toscana offers upscale dining and fine Italian cuisine in Staten Island. High-quality ingredients, tender meats, fresh produce, and traditional seasonings are carefully combined to create exceptional dishes that deliver an authentic Italian dining experience. Enjoy handmade pasta, fine wines, and great service in Trattoria Toscana's comfortable dining room. It's a wonderful date night spot or special occasion venue, and you can tell the owners, chefs, and staff really take pride in the restaurant.

Comments / 6

Published by

Local reporting on Delmarva. For inquiries:

Snow Hill, MD

More from Katie Cherrix

Comments / 0