New York City, NY

Opinion: New York Should Import Foreign Transit Construction Workers And Consultants

C. Heslop

A 400-page report by NY University researchers revealed shocking failures by the MTA.

MTA is the Metropolitan Transportation Authority. It is a public benefit corporation managing transit in the NYC metropolitan area. What did the researchers discover? The MTA failed to supervise the firms hired. They drew bespoke escalators, over-staffed the project, and dug extra-large platform caverns.

The transit team cannot complete projects on time and within budget. It causes higher taxes and fares. The public also gets less of the services that officials promised.

Eric Goldwyn is one of the authors of the report. Eric said, "Other places in the world – in Madrid, in four years, they built 80 miles of subway. We've built just a mile."

"We're doing dramatically less and spending dramatically more, so future projects are in peril," he continues. "With Phase 2 [of the Second Avenue Subway], they're still trying to get all the funding together."

The MTA has a debt of over $40 billion and spends $3 billion per year on payments. The research paper studied the first phase of the Second Avenue Subway. At the time of the study, this phase was the most expensive subway project in the world.

The team assessed the construction of new transit lines across the globe. Countries like Istanbul, Rome, Paris, London, and Stockholm built railways for a fraction of the cost.

Where does MTA spend transit capital?

The researchers found that "among its global peers, the MTA is uniquely dependent on consultants and contractors to design, engineer, and manage projects. It then fails to properly oversee the hired help, allowing projects to balloon in size and get bogged down in delays."

How do Europeans spend transit capital?

"European transit agencies perform the bulk of their project design, engineering, and construction management with white-collar agency staff instead of relying on outside entities. And when they hire outside firms, they keep them on a short leash." (source)
"In Europe, transit agencies have standardized the designs of their stations to cut down on engineering costs, speed construction, and repairs." (source)


What do you think?

Comment your thoughts, and feel free to share this article on social media.

*Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only. This article got written using accredited media reports. Below are affiliate links. It is an opinion piece based on news and analysis by New York Post. *Advice Disclaimer: The article and the information contained herein are not intended to be a source of advice.

Gift Coffee | Claim your free Newsbreak account | Earn cash online

Comments / 3

Published by

Food, Relationships, Money, Social Media, and Business.


More from C. Heslop

Comments / 0