Opinion: Alabama Supreme Court is Asked "Life or Embryo?"

Ashleigh Nicole
Image by brgfxPhoto byFreepik

Ladies and gentlemen, we find ourselves in a legal conundrum here in Alabama that's about as complex as a Rubik's Cube. At the heart of it all is the question: Can embryos be legally considered human beings?

The Plaintiff's Case

A group of six plaintiffs is taking their case to the Alabama Supreme Court after their initial lawsuit was dismissed in 2022. Their claim? The Center for Reproductive Medicine allowed a patient to destroy embryos they considered their children. The couples had entrusted the clinic with creating embryos, some of which were stored there. In December 2020, a patient somehow got into the clinic, accessed the cryogenic nursery, and accidentally dropped the embryos due to their extremely cold temperature.

The Defense's Argument

Now, the crux of this matter is whether embryos are, in essence, human beings. The clinic's argument is straightforward: embryos may be human, but they're not human beings because they lack a beating heart. On the other side of the ring, the couples contend that, from the moment of fertilization, embryos possess unique DNA, traits, and the potential for life, making them human beings.

Alabama Law

Alabama's state legislature defines an "unborn child" as an individual organism of the species homo sapiens from fertilization until live birth, encompassing all stages of development. The clinic counters that this definition applies only to embryos inside a woman's uterus.

The clinic's lawyers also accuse the couples of bringing this case into the political arena, attempting to tie it to recent laws on active pregnancies and abortion rights. The plaintiffs, represented by attorney Dave Wirtes, argue that regardless of whether the wrongful death claim stands, the clinic should be held accountable for negligence, emphasizing the responsibility to safeguard and protect these embryos when you're in the business of creating them.

Motivation Behind Legal Pursuit

On one hand, you can argue that an embryo, with its unique DNA and potential for life, might indeed be considered a human being, and what happened could be seen as wrongful death. But let's go a bit deeper into the motivations behind this lawsuit. Are the couples seeking a financial windfall, essentially asking for a refund for an incomplete service? Or are they genuinely mourning the loss of what they already considered family members?

The demand for compensatory damages, including the value of the embryos, as well as claims of severe mental anguish and emotional distress, raises questions. And let's not forget that there was a contract signed beforehand, possibly safeguarding the clinic against situations like this. So, what's really going on here? It's a puzzle that begs for a closer look to understand the true motives and implications of this legal battle.

Final Thoughts

This case goes deep into philosophical and legal territory, challenging our understanding of life and personhood. When does life truly begin? Can embryos, in their earliest stages, be considered human beings deserving of legal protection? It's a complex matter that the Alabama Supreme Court now has the unenviable task of unraveling. The outcome of this case could have profound implications far beyond the state's borders, making it one to watch closely.

Let me know your thoughts in the comments. Please share this story on social media if you enjoyed reading it!

As always, thank you for reading! Your support means a lot. You can follow my work on X (formerly Twitter) @PressRealz, and my newsletter. Got a story you want me to track down? Let me know in an email to newsbreakcontributor@gmail.com

This is original content from NewsBreak’s Creator Program. Join today to publish and share your own content.

Comments / 1

Published by

Ashleigh Nicole is an Alabama-based writer and freelancer, bringing a unique blend of culinary expertise and creative storytelling to the world of writing. The former executive chef at a prominent French bistro was forced to rethink career choice after COVID-19. She is now a truth seeker and news junkie sharing what she finds with her audience. Drawing from her diverse experiences, Ashleigh now uses her storytelling abilities to captivate readers and offer a fresh perspective.

Alabama State

More from Ashleigh Nicole

Comments / 0